Skip to main content
** NEW FLAVORS**
** NEW FLAVORS**

The Finest Flavors

Morgenstern's Finest Pies

Order pies online for pickup at Greenwich Village NYC location

Pair your pie with one of our 54 ice cream flavors and make it à la mode!  All pies require 48 hours notice prior to pick-up.  Pies serve 8 full sized slices but can accommodate up to 10.

morgenstern's finest pecan pumpkin apple pie nyc pickup available with ice cream
  • Filter
  • Pickup Only
  • Pies
Out of stock
$42.00

Pork Lard Apple Pie

Thanksgiving pie pre-orders for Wednesday pick-up have closed as of 4pm on 11/22. There will be s...
$42.00

Pumpkin Pie with Sweet Butter Crust

Thick, rich pumpkin custard sets up perfectly in our sweet butter crust in this Thanksgiving clas...
$42.00

Pecan Pie with Sweet Butter Crust

Suggested Ice Cream: Bourbon Vanilla, Chocolate Oat, Butter Pecan.
$42.00

Bourbon Pecan Pie with Chocolate Crust

 
Bourbon and chocolate make this classic that much more indulgent.  Pecans are set in a brown su...
$52.00

Peanut Butter Chocolate Ice Cream Pie

Chocolate and Peanut Butter Ice Cream, Chocolate Crust, Whipped Cream Top
 
STORING/SERVING INSTR...
$52.00

Lemon Meringue Ice Cream Pie

A Frozen American Classic - Lemon Curd ice cream in a graham cracker crust, with toasted meringue...

Follow us