Skip to main content
VIEW FLAVORS
VIEW FLAVORS

The Finest Flavors

Morgenstern's Finest Pies

Order pies online for pickup at Greenwich Village NYC location

Pair your pie with one of our 54 ice cream flavors and make it à la mode!  All pies require 48 hours notice prior to pick-up.  Pies serve 8 full sized slices but can accommodate up to 10.

morgenstern's finest pecan pumpkin apple pie nyc pickup available with ice cream
  • Filter
  • Pickup Only
  • Pies
Out of stock
$42.00

Pork Lard Apple Pie

Thanksgiving pie pre-orders for Wednesday pick-up have closed as of 4pm on 11/22. There will be s...
Out of stock
$42.00

Pumpkin Pie with Sweet Butter Crust

Thick, rich pumpkin custard sets up perfectly in our sweet butter crust in this Thanksgiving clas...
Out of stock
$42.00

Pecan Pie with Sweet Butter Crust

Suggested Ice Cream: Bourbon Vanilla, Chocolate Oat, Butter Pecan.
Out of stock
$42.00

Bourbon Pecan Pie with Chocolate Crust

 
Bourbon and chocolate make this classic that much more indulgent.  Pecans are set in a brown su...
$52.00

Peanut Butter Chocolate Ice Cream Pie

Chocolate and Peanut Butter Ice Cream, Chocolate Crust, Whipped Cream Top
 
STORING/SERVING INSTR...
$52.00

Lemon Meringue Ice Cream Pie

A Frozen American Classic - Lemon Curd ice cream in a graham cracker crust, with toasted meringue...

Follow us