Custom Ice Cream Cakes


Order a custom Morgensterns Ice Cream Cake for your next event or celebration.

How to place a custom cake order?

  1. Please place your order for the size you would like and check out through Shopify
  2. Complete our Ice Cream Cake Order Form to select your flavors and toppings

Unfortunately, we are not able to accommodate special decorating requests at this time. All ice cream cakes come with an optional second ice cream flavor and an optional topping. For any additional inquiries, email us at

Pickup Hours


Please order 48 hours in advance of pick-up time


88 Houston Street New York, NY 10012

Please provide 48-hours advance notice for online orders. Call ahead about same day availability. Ice cream should be picked-up 24 hours in advance of serving so it can come to the perfect scoop-able temperature in your home freezer. All pricing includes NY sales tax.