Thank you for your interest in our Thanksgiving pies for 2016! This year we have 7 sweet pie creations for you to choose from:

Pumpkin Pie with Sugar Cone Crust $36
Salted Caramel Custard Pie with Pretzel Crust $36
Cinnamon Apple Pie with Pork Lard Crust $38
Bourbon Pecan Pie with Sweet Dough $40

Exclusive pies in collaboration with Mario Batali inspired by his book, Mario Batali's Big American Cookbook: 

Indian Custard Pie with Cornbread Crust $36
Maple, Molasses, and Cornbread born as a hasty pudding

Mississippi Mud Pie $45
Chocolate Pudding meet Chocolate Cake.
Chocolate Cake meet Chocolate Pudding.
Chocolate Crust Meet Marshmallows.
Marshmallows meet Chocolate Crust.

Butterscotch Pie with Sweet Dough $38
Dark Brown Sugar with Caramel Creamy.
"Just add Salted Pretzel Caramel Ice Cream Please."

Pre-packed pints of ice cream are available at a special price of $9 each for Thanksgiving pie orders only. Additional ice cream can be purchased for $11 (pint) or $48 (half-gallon).

Pies will be available for order from Tuesday November 1st through Tuesday November 22 at 6pm. Please provide 48-hour advance notice for all pies/ice cream cakes. In-store pick-up only.

A limited number of pies will also be available for purchase in-store on Tuesday November 22 and Wednesday November 23, subject to availability. Please call ahead about same day availability.

Please note that orders for pick-up on Tuesday November 22 and Wednesday November 23 will close at 6pm the day before.

Pick-up for all pies will be available from 8am - 11pm Tuesday November 22 and 8am - 9pm Wednesday November 23, excluding Morgenstern's Cinnamon Apple Pie which will be available for pick-up from 9am.